Maker Pro
Maker Pro

total lumen output of multiple lamps

J

JohnR66

Would the total lumen output of two 3000 lumen lamps equal 6000
lumens?

I need to compare one F96T12CW with two T8 lamps.

Yes.

In some cases, with electronic ballasts, I notice adding the second bulb
causes the first bulb to dim just a bit as the ballast gets loaded. I can't
say if that the second bulb is causing the current to come down to rated
current or fall below. At any rate, ballast factor must be addressed when
comparing lumens.
 
A

Andrew Gabriel

Yes.

In some cases, with electronic ballasts, I notice adding the second bulb
causes the first bulb to dim just a bit as the ballast gets loaded. I can't
say if that the second bulb is causing the current to come down to rated
current or fall below. At any rate, ballast factor must be addressed when
comparing lumens.

There are other effects too. For example, the positioning of
the second lamp is likely to create a shadow of the first
lamp in most practical scenarios, i.e. some of the light from
the first lamp enters the second lamp. Whilst a little of this
might be reflected/refracted out again, much of it will be
absorbed and lost, resulting in output which is less than the
sum of the two by themselves. This is actually an issue for any
type of folded or bent tube too, as used in compact fluorescents,
where much of the light can be lost into other parts of the tube.
In most designs, when you look at the tube, there is a significant
portion of the tube you can't see because it's obscured behind
another tube section, i.e. you're in its shadow. It's pretty much
only linear tubes which don't have this issue.
 
T

TKM

Would the total lumen output of two 3000 lumen lamps equal 6000
lumens?

I need to compare one F96T12CW with two T8 lamps.

Lumens add, so you can do a rough calculation to see how the T12 lamp
compares with the two T8s. But, to take fixture optics, ballast factor and
operating temperature differences into account, compare the two situations
using the respective luminaire coefficients of utilization (CUs). If this
is a retrofit situation involving existing fixtures, take the ballast factor
into account at least. Note that you can now find some ballasts with BFs
over 1.0 for some lamp/ballast combinations if you should need more light.

Terry McGowan
 
Top