Maker Pro
Maker Pro

shorting collector and emitter of a laptop fan transistor

Hi everybody!
I got a small problem concerning a laptop fan. During the first 30 minutes (more or less) it didn't work properly: it only started spinning immediately after having turned my laptop on after a system shutdown caused by the excess of CPU temperature (excess of temperature obviously due to the "absence" of the CPU fan). But then once on, the fan kept spinning for about 10-20 seconds before stopping again. So, once again the CPU temperature started rising until the forced shutdown. This kind of process occurred 3-4 times in 30 minutes. In this time span, the CPU fan seemed to be in oblivion and only worked at very high temperatures.
After these 30 minutes the fan started working regularly, even for hours!

Explained this problem, someone told me that it could easily depend on cold joints and a reflow of some components would have been the best solution in these cases. But I don't have a hot gun and neither do people I know. So I preferred to do some tests that someone advised.
Then I managed to reset the bios but nothing changed. I forgot to say that in the first 30 minutes my motherboard often blinked (caps lock and num lock).
At last, I found a quicker solution: to short connector and emitter of a darlington transistor that controls the CPU fan:
2pskkdj.jpg


Now, it would be very intesting to know any possible disadvantage of this choice, such as energy consumption, transistor lifetime (as well as the ones of the other components that might be affected by the permanent spinning of the CPU fan) and other issues that would arise.
Anyway, thanks to a very small piece of copper (the end of a wire) put between collector and emitter, I tested my laptop for a few hours and it seemed that the full-speed fan didn't cause any problem and CPU temperature was well below acceptable limits.
Strange as it may seem, the DDR fan didn't even turn on, perhaps because CPU was always "mild" and so processor didn't give any signal to let the DDR fan start spinning. But I did want even the DDR fan running, so I did the same trick of joining connector and emitter. Now, I have 2 fans at full speed but I need to remove the temporary piece of copper and make this modification definitive.
There is just 1 mm between the 2 pins, so someone suggested to add a drop of solder in-between (without copper or any other material). Is the best solution if I don't want to waste time to unsolder the transistor? Does it guarantee a good electrical conductivity (and then a constant short between collector and emitter)? It should be a micro solder. I got a WS-70DA soldering iron that is not very precise for this kind of tasks. But I am going to practice a little bit before soldering on my motherboard.

Other issue concerns the noise. With 2 fans spinning at full speed I got to wear something to protect my ears... For this reason, someone suggested to put a resistor in order to decrease a bit the speed of the fan. For a DC 5V 0.30A fan, how many ohms should I need? Consider that often the CPU fan spinned at high speed (though not full speed), when my laptop worked in normal conditions. So I cannot exagerate with the ohms. But where and how putting the resistor in such a small available space? And what kind of resistor? Only SMD resistors?
 
I think that it is always a good idea not to short the circuit. The fact that the fan will always run does not necessarily mean that cpu will run cool enough and i advise you not to put a resistor to drop fan rpm because at heavy cpu load the fan will not be able to supply enough air to cool the heatsink.

Have you cleaned the heatsing and put fresh compound ? This is very important and might solve your problem.
 
Last edited:
I agree with you but the point is that heatsink and fan cleaning is the very first thing I did, followed by the application of my thermal compound.
As far as the resistor is concerned, I wasn't really convinced with the idea of putting a resistor just for the reasons you rightly explained.

I haven't reflowed my motherboard yet basically because I don't have a hot gun and neither do people I know. I just have a soldering iron but it wouldn't be effective like a hot gun.
I've looked for the quickest and cheapest solution: adding a drop of solder to short those 2 pins takes a few minutes and no costs, while buying a hot gun has its costs and no one can guarantee that it will be successful.
I tested my motherboard with the 2 fans on and at full speed for a few hours. From the heatsink always came out a mild air.
An alternative, that most people advised, would be a reflow of the electrical components. Perhaps, at very last I should try this before the permanent modification I'm willing to do. Anyway, I would run some risks by using hot gun. If I'm not enough careful, I'm going to unsolder some of the closest components, closest to the ones directly affected by the air flow. And what about the components on the same area but of the opposite side of the motherboard? Would they run the risk to be unsoldered and fall to the ground (for the law of gravity)?
 
Top