Maker Pro
Maker Pro

Rigol DSA 815

C

Charles

This is a moderately priced spectrum analyzer covering 9 kHz to 1.5 Ghz with
a tracking generator option.

If you do RF, check it out.

No affiliation with Rigol. None. Nada.
 
J

josephkk

This is a moderately priced spectrum analyzer covering 9 kHz to 1.5 Ghz with
a tracking generator option.

If you do RF, check it out.

No affiliation with Rigol. None. Nada.

It seems right nice for the price point. But for my use case Jan P.'s
design is a better deal.

?-)
 
J

Jamie

josephkk said:
It seems right nice for the price point. But for my use case Jan P.'s
design is a better deal.

?-)

I still think that 1.5Ghz is marginal with today's gear. Either a
block converter or one that can do at least 5Ghz would be more appropriate.

It would be nice to be able to at least look at the common 2.5Ghz band.

I have looked at that unit and while it has some nice standard
features and a good paint job, I think I would rather throw in some more
money to get one that does at least twice the BW.

Just my opinion from the peanut gallery....

Jamie
 
T

tuinkabouter

It seems right nice for the price point. But for my use case Jan P.'s
design is a better deal.

Why do you even think about buying from a spammer?
 
C

Charles

"Jamie" wrote in message
It seems right nice for the price point. But for my use case Jan P.'s
design is a better deal.

?-)

I still think that 1.5Ghz is marginal with today's gear. Either a
block converter or one that can do at least 5Ghz would be more appropriate.

It would be nice to be able to at least look at the common 2.5Ghz band.

I have looked at that unit and while it has some nice standard
features and a good paint job, I think I would rather throw in some more
money to get one that does at least twice the BW.

Just my opinion from the peanut gallery....

Agreed. It costs more to go faster (sample higher):
http://www.rigolna.com/products/spectrum-analyzers/dsa1000a/dsa1030a-tg3/

The 815 does a lot although limited in frequency, but is nevertheless a very
good buy. A frequency down converter would be nice. Any ideas?

I am impressed with its performance/cost ratio.
 
C

Charles

"Charles" wrote in message
This is a moderately priced spectrum analyzer covering 9 kHz to 1.5 Ghz with
a tracking generator option.

If you do RF, check it out.

No affiliation with Rigol. None. Nada.

http://www.tmworld.com/electronics-...duct-review--Rigol-DSA815TG-spectrum-analyzer

It is worth looking at. I have been using it a lot and find that (so far)
it meets its specs. Also, you can "print" to a flash drive and then easily
transfer the image (the display screen) to your computer. Nice!
 
J

JW

This is a moderately priced spectrum analyzer covering 9 kHz to 1.5 Ghz with
a tracking generator option.

If you do RF, check it out.

No affiliation with Rigol. None. Nada.

No thanks. For a little more money ($3K) I could get an Agilent 8562A good
to 22GHz.
 
L

Leif Neland

JW har bragt dette til verden:
No thanks. For a little more money ($3K) I could get an Agilent 8562A good
to 22GHz.

So $3K is just a little more money than $1,295 ?

Nice to know your reference...

Leif
 
J

JW

JW har bragt dette til verden:

So $3K is just a little more money than $1,295 ?

Nice to know your reference...

In addition to what Michael said; When and if something goes wrong with
the HP, I have the complete set of service manuals with component level
information - I can fix it myself. Parts are plentiful for the HP as well.
What about the Rigol?
 
N

Nico Coesel

JW said:
In addition to what Michael said; When and if something goes wrong with
the HP, I have the complete set of service manuals with component level
information - I can fix it myself. Parts are plentiful for the HP as well.
What about the Rigol?

By the time your Rigol breaks down, Ebay will be swamped with 'for
parts' units.
 
J

JW

All needing the same parts, or they wouldn't be on Ebay.

Probably. I wouldn't be surprised if it consists of 1 or 2 circuit boards
loaded with all sorts of chips that cannot be removed economically (BGA,
etc.) by your average tech. And with no service data, you likely wouldn't
be able to figure out what needed replacing anyway.
 
N

Nico Coesel

JW said:
Probably. I wouldn't be surprised if it consists of 1 or 2 circuit boards
loaded with all sorts of chips that cannot be removed economically (BGA,
etc.) by your average tech. And with no service data, you likely wouldn't
be able to figure out what needed replacing anyway.

It seems you have very little experience with repairing equipment.
What breaks most often is the PSU, inputs or outputs. These are mostly
built around standard chips and easy to repair (especially true for
modern low and mid range equipment). If the logic gets defective it is
usually caused by the power supply going wrong. And then there are the
occasional bad solder joints but those are rare. All in all most
equipment can be serviced even without a service manual as long as you
think logically.
 
F

Fred Abse

I still think that 1.5Ghz is marginal with today's gear. Either a
block converter or one that can do at least 5Ghz would be more appropriate.

It's not so much the first converter, as the first LO, that would add to
the cost. Continuously, linearly, sweeping over a 5GHz range is not
exactly cheap.
 
N

Nico Coesel

Fred Abse said:
It's not so much the first converter, as the first LO, that would add to
the cost. Continuously, linearly, sweeping over a 5GHz range is not
exactly cheap.

Nowadays you don't need to sweep linear. As long as the frequency is
known the CPU knows where to put the dot on the display.
 
J

JW

It seems you have very little experience with repairing equipment.

You'd be wrong in your assumption. I've probably repaired more test
equipment in my life than you've ever even seen. I worked for 3 years for
a fairly large used test equipment company ( www.techrecovery.com ) as
their only component level tech. When I realized I could make a whole lot
more money buying broken equipment, doing the repairs, and reselling on
Ebay, I left them.

ObShameless Plug:
http://www.ebay.com/sch/techman7734/m.html?_nkw=&_armrs=1&_from=&_ipg=&_trksid=p3686

Although my stock is a bit low at the moment as in Jan and Feb I sold over
$25K worth of equipment, if anyone sees anything they like, I'd knock 10%
off on a private sale. ;)

At this point there are several used equipment dealers who send their
stuff to *me* for repair.
What breaks most often is the PSU, inputs or outputs.

Of course.
These are mostly
built around standard chips and easy to repair (especially true for
modern low and mid range equipment). If the logic gets defective it is
usually caused by the power supply going wrong. And then there are the
occasional bad solder joints but those are rare. All in all most
equipment can be serviced even without a service manual as long as you
think logically.

Sometimes that is true, but many times not. I've seen just about
everything under the sun go wrong or bad. Likely because I've repaired
thousands of instruments.
 
G

George Herold

You'd be wrong in your assumption. I've probably repaired more test
equipment in my life than you've ever even seen. I worked for 3 years for
a fairly large used test equipment company (www.techrecovery.com) as
their only component level tech. When I realized I could make a whole lot
more money buying broken equipment, doing the repairs, and reselling on
Ebay, I left them.

ObShameless Plug:http://www.ebay.com/sch/techman7734/m.html?_nkw=&_armrs=1&_from=&_ipg...

Neat! Say the four channel Aglient 'scope 54831B for only ~$600 looks
like a steal. Is this 600MHz? Is there something wrong with it? (I
wonder if my wife will let me buy another 'scope?)

Re the Rigol: I think Dave did a tear down of it on his eevblog.

George H.
 
N

Nico Coesel

JW said:
You'd be wrong in your assumption. I've probably repaired more test
equipment in my life than you've ever even seen. I worked for 3 years for

And you never seen a teardown of a Rigol scope :)
a fairly large used test equipment company ( www.techrecovery.com ) as
their only component level tech. When I realized I could make a whole lot
more money buying broken equipment, doing the repairs, and reselling on
Ebay, I left them.

It seems the used equipment market is so much better at your end. I
recently restored a TDS544A but its hardly worth the effort from a
financial perspective. And I was extremely lucky someone offered a
working color CRT board for an absolute bargain. Perhaps it was the
shortest buy-it-now offering on Ebay ever :)
Sometimes that is true, but many times not. I've seen just about
everything under the sun go wrong or bad. Likely because I've repaired
thousands of instruments.

I've done some repair work in the past but mostly the cases other
people couldn't fix. Nowadays I only fix equipment for my own use. Or
just convert the CRT or STN screens to TFT screens.
 
N

Nico Coesel

George Herold said:
s=3D1&_from=3D&_ipg...

Neat! Say the four channel Aglient 'scope 54831B for only ~$600 looks
like a steal. Is this 600MHz? Is there something wrong with it? (I
wonder if my wife will let me buy another 'scope?)

That one caught my eye as well but if you read carefully the $600 will
get it 'upgraded' to Windows XP.
 
Top