S
Sunny
Bill said:Both of your points are good, and I don't have answers. I wouldn't
expect the two coils to be interchangable.
A PM-based alternator would certainly work in the sense of producing
power. I just don't know how a regulator would work. If there is 170
volts at full throttle, and the alternator can produce, say, 20 amps,
then a linear regulator that regulates 170 volts down to 14 volts would
dissipate 156V x 20 amps = 3120 watts! That is clearly ludicrous - but
I don't know how else it would regulate if you can't reduce the voltage
via a field coil. Maybe it's like a cycle-counting light dimmer? I'm
not convinced that would work, either.
I guess I'm out of my area of expertise, so I will wish you luck and
fade back into lurking mode.
Once again, Bill makes good sense even when out of his depth
You've confirmed my thoughts - there's no reasonable way to regulate an
AC input which varies from 15-170v to a constant 12-14v DC, therefore
the input must be controlled, presumably via a field coil.
We know that a permanent magnet alternator *can* be designed with a
field coil, since that's the scheme described in the service manual I
was reading on the weekend - but unfortunately this particular manual is
third party, and written in colloquial language by an author clearly
more comfortable with mechanical things - his description of the
alternator theory of operation was amusing but not particularly
illuminating I'll read it again this weekend and see if I can't
glean a better understanding.
The alternator output current probably falls somewhere between your
estimate and Ken's, given my old manual contains a paragraph detailing
how to determine whether you are dealing with a 9 amp or 15 amp
alternator - apparently a given motor might been fitted with either.
Thanks again, and I'll post updates as appropriate.
Sunny