The Seem filter has only one Y capacitor and a much smaller inductance: 0.1uF X + 4700pF Y + 2 x 4mH. So I find it unsuitable, but it's better than nothing.
The RS filter has no data/values printed on it so I really can't say, but at least it has two Y capacitors like your original. Lacking alternatives I'd go for that one.
It will surely do a good enough job. Given that it has a 1A rating the inductance is likely greater than in the 2.5A Seem filter.