hevans1944
Hop - AC8NS
I didn't realize you and Mark were having a private conversation. He started one with me, too, but it hasn't gone anywhere.In a conversation, Mark said that he wants blocking and unblocking the light from the phototransistor to turn the load LED on and off and if replacing the SCR with a transistor will do it (like I explained in my last post here) and I said yes, but I also explained all the missing details that are important to do the actual design.
If this is, indeed, a high-speed photo-flash application, then the SCR provides the inherent positive feedback necessary for fast triggering of the flash tube. Later, on the same website page, it is mentioned that a Schmitt trigger is necessary for "slow moving" objects interrupting the light beam. The authors suggest using the 555 timer IC to obtain the fast trigger transition for the SCR. But, if fast triggering is NOT an objective, then replacing the SCR with a bi-polar junction transistor (BJT) is a viable option.