Jitter is a function of the phase noise profile.
Set your jitter spec., calculate your jitter from the phase noise
of your chosen oscillator.
Then you don't need to argue with anybody.
It's not difficult.
At what kind of offsets from the carrier should the phase noise
profile be measured, to give meaningful jitter characteristic ?
At least for measuring phase noise for oscillators for RF applications
(especially first LO), it is very hard to get meaningfully readings
within +/-1 kHz from carrier, even with high quality test equipment,
unless you use some deep crystal notch filters at the carrier
frequency.