Mike said:
So it isn't suitable for starting with shorted loads.
As I said, there is no such thing as 'bad', just more or less appropriate for any given situation.
This circuit is not appropriate for situations where the load may be shorted at startup.
try "where the load may be shorted, ever"
nor is it appropriate when you care about load regulation, line
regulation or efficiency
his current-limited version is even worse. when current limiting into a
short, it turns into a linear regulator......full current, full voltage.
yes there is indeed such a thing as BAD, and this circuit is one
example. Its OK if you are a hobbyist, and really dont care much about
how well your circuit works (Mr Blacks push-in prototype board
construction is a great example) or what the reliability is like;
conversely for a real application, its a disaster.
Cheers
Terry