Maker Pro
Maker Pro

Someone doing electronics? Wow...

T

Tim Williams

Getting back to my induction heater, well first I removed the two dead
transistors from last time I had it out, and then I got to work
investigating why they died. The circuit seems just peachy at 130VDC,
putting out a clean 230W into a light load (1uH coil, resonant around
35kHz). But hmm, something I hadn't noticed before, trash on the falling
edge. Let's take a closer look at that, hmm and only on the falling edge
you say?

Hey, the high side gate drive is flying with the output, isn't it. If
there's enough capacitive coupling in the pulse transformer -- and with a
40ns edge, there is -- it could turn on again. Or off, as the case may be.
Ya know, I recall the gate drive has a couple hundred ns propagation
delay...isn't that curiously near the bouncing frequency? Gack...

For pics see ABSE.

Now I'm gonna go put in TTL-style outputs (i.e., emitter-follower-buffered
collector output with diode from emitter to collector) and see if that
helps any. Then maybe complementary emitter followers, although I don't
think the 1.2V class-C offset is quite good enough, and I don't want to
bother biasing the things. Hopefully it's just an impedance issue at the
transformer and nothing worse...

Another option is to intentionally slow down the oscillator outputs,
literally bypassing the HF-trash with a so-called bypass cap. The emitter
followers will still give sharp edges, but I don't need sharp turn-on, I
need sharp turn-off, so maybe I would do that with the collector driven
layout instead.

I could also slow down the output's edge itself by, pffbt, easily a
microsecond, drastically reducing HF-trash. (Which is a good thing anyway,
since my digital panel meter is reading bonkers half the time and I see
little tone bursts on everything.) Old fashioned snubber capacitor stuff.
So how much and how to connect? Well, right now I've got 20A peak current,
so for delta 130V / delta 1us, that's 0.15uF, with a peak rating over 20A
obviously... one of those MKPs from my tank cap would do it. I wonder how
happy the bridge would be switching into that though. I remember having a
hard time getting the desat to switch into even a resistive load, though
that was an earlier implementation. Maybe a series resistor could be
used -- say, 10% drop at peak current, or 13 / 20 = 0.65 ohms. Gee, rather
small, and still a short-circuit current of 200A from this modest supply
voltage...

Oh, and something Terry Given might like to hear: my desat protection DOES
work (at least on the low side): I was prodding around the high side, saw a
blue spark and thought OH SHIT IT'S FUCKED, slowly coming to realize that
1. supply voltage is still there and 2. the reset light is on... hmm turn
off and check continuity, the IGBTs are still good... woohoo!

Tim
 
T

Tim Williams

- Trying the TTL-ish outputs didn't make much difference, but 0.1uF
directly across the output rail makes it surprisingly clean (my digital
panel meter stopped hunting...), although at low current (circa 10A) the
transistors chomp into it, making the rails ring a bit. This could be
avoided by dropping the PWM chip's duty cycle, which I do have available in
potentiometer form. At higher current (lower frequency, since the load is
inductive) it cleans up just fine. The oscillator waveforms likewise are
much cleaner.

Tim
 
T

Tim Williams

Hey, um, I seem to have a problem: I used an MKP type polypropylene cap for
the snubber, which works nicely, except that... when I turn up the juice
(namely 320VDC supply), it gets noticably warm and, after a while, swells!
It's not a particularly beefy unit, but still, I count 30A peak and 9.4A
RMS through the poor thing! It's probably good for 1, maybe 2A RMS tops.

So I turn to my handy Mouser Catalog 634, and flip around to, oh, Cornell
Dubilier 935's. But the size I need (~0.1uF) starts at 1000VDC, and even
then it's "only" rated for 8.something A RMS. And if I'm going to get one
of those expensive suckers, it's got to be rated for full power, which is
at least double the current, and they aren't!

Of course, I could go with one of those so-called "IGBT Snubber"
capacitors, but they're made for modules, and I don't have any modules.

So what do you all use for snubbers when it's a measly 10kW or less? I'm
leaning towards smaller MKPs, something like the Epcos high pulse rated
630V 0.033uF (see data at Digikey), and paralleling a bunch, like I did
with every other damn cap in this project, but I can't help but feel like
I'm missing something obvious here...

Tim

--
Deep Fryer: A very philosophical monk.
Website @ http://webpages.charter.net/dawill/tmoranwms

....
I could also slow down the output's edge itself by, pffbt, easily a
microsecond, drastically reducing HF-trash. (Which is a good thing anyway,
since my digital panel meter is reading bonkers half the time and I see
little tone bursts on everything.) Old fashioned snubber capacitor
stuff.
 
T

Tim Williams

James Waldby said:
Some oil-filled high voltage capacitors like the $20 items at
http://www.electronicsurplus.com/ccc1686-capacitors.htm may be rated
ok for your induction heating circuits.

You mean for the snubber? I've already got:
http://webpages.charter.net/dawill/tmoranwms/Elec_CapBank.html
for the tank.
Another source for oil-filled HV caps is Surplus Sales of Nebraska,
http://www.surplussales.com/Capacitors/OilCaps/OilCapIndex.html .

Hmm, offhand I'm not seeing anything of interest.

Tim
 
T

Tim Williams

James Waldby said:
Yes. You were talking about 10A RMS / 0.1uF / 1000VDC for the
snubber. The items at electronicsurplus are several times that
capacitance which (from what little I know about snubbers) is ok.
My thought is that physically-larger caps like these will hold up
better. (However, I don't know what ringing frequency you need to
suppress, hence whether they will be in spec.)

Well, big capacitance eats into dV/dt. I need to slow dV/dt, because big
dV/dt apparently blows transistors and sprays gangbusters RFI. But I can't
slow it too far, I need a minimum of, oh, let's say 150V/us to get a
reasonable squarewave at 20kHz. 300V/us is pretty good up to 50kHz, which
is the highest frequency I want to cover. So I really can't afford much
capacitance, and that concerns me because all the beefy capacitors (like
the Cornell Dubilier 935's Mouser and Allied sell) seem to be 1uF or more.

One of those big bastards, like I think it was on the Nebraska site I saw
an IGBT snubber capacitor module, made to bolt directly onto buss bars-
rated something like 1200V and 40uF. That's going to be perfect for like,
traction control IGBTs, or something relatively slow like that. Probably a
good couple hundred amps, and switching under 1kHz. Hundreds of kVA, a
little out of my scope -- although if I were building an induction heater
that size, it would go about that frequency.

Tim
 
T

Tim Williams

JosephKK said:
At the power levels you are using i hope that you did nor forget an
ohm or so of series resistance.

On the snubber capacitor? I tried one initially (0.47 ohm), but it wasn't
rated for enough power and started stinking. ;-) That was at 100V. I
don't have any resistors small enough in value, low inductance and large
enough in power to serve.

Without a resistor seems to work okay (at least after the first half
cycle), why?

Tim
 
J

JosephKK

On the snubber capacitor? I tried one initially (0.47 ohm), but it wasn't
rated for enough power and started stinking. ;-) That was at 100V. I
don't have any resistors small enough in value, low inductance and large
enough in power to serve.

Without a resistor seems to work okay (at least after the first half
cycle), why?

Tim

Hmmm. Do you know / can you measure the ESR and ESL of the capacitor.
 
T

Tim Williams

JosephKK said:
Hmmm. Do you know / can you measure the ESR and ESL of the capacitor.

Specs:
http://www.alliedelec.com/Images/Products/Datasheets/BM/ILLINOIS_CAPACITOR/
Illinois-Capacitor_Actives-and-Passives_6130623.pdf
(Beware line wrap; Mfr. # 104MKP275K at Allied)
ESL: <= 1nH/mm along pitch and lead length
ESR: not listed. I would guess 50-100mohm, typical for an MKP this size.
dV/dt peak = 300V/us.

I was using it at rated dV/dt, but way too often, evidently. Even if it's
50mohm (but given the small size, I'd err on the high side!), the 8.5A RMS
I calculated it was passing gives 3.6W dissipated inside the thing -- not
going to take that for long.

I probably could estimate the ESL and ESR in circuit, as there's a
miniscule blip as the capacitor catches the transistor's collector current
during turn-off.

Yesterday I recieved new snubber capacitors (and some more replacement
transistors...) so I can try this again with *real* snubber capacitors.
8.5A RMS through 7mohm is only 0.5W, and they're a lot larger than these
MKPs!

Tim
 
J

JosephKK

Specs:
http://www.alliedelec.com/Images/Products/Datasheets/BM/ILLINOIS_CAPACITOR/
Illinois-Capacitor_Actives-and-Passives_6130623.pdf
(Beware line wrap; Mfr. # 104MKP275K at Allied)
ESL: <= 1nH/mm along pitch and lead length
ESR: not listed. I would guess 50-100mohm, typical for an MKP this size.
dV/dt peak = 300V/us.

I was using it at rated dV/dt, but way too often, evidently. Even if it's
50mohm (but given the small size, I'd err on the high side!), the 8.5A RMS
I calculated it was passing gives 3.6W dissipated inside the thing -- not
going to take that for long.

I probably could estimate the ESL and ESR in circuit, as there's a
miniscule blip as the capacitor catches the transistor's collector current
during turn-off.

Yesterday I recieved new snubber capacitors (and some more replacement
transistors...) so I can try this again with *real* snubber capacitors.
8.5A RMS through 7mohm is only 0.5W, and they're a lot larger than these
MKPs!

Tim

Sounds like you are on a better track now. I might have been late to
the game, but maybe i asked you a worthwhile question.
 
Top