Maker Pro
Maker Pro

electron beam through solenoid coil

J

Jamie M

Hi,

How does a solenoid act to focus a beam of electrons that are passed
axially through the coil?

cheers,
Jamie
 
C

Carl Ijames

Well, assume the electron beam begins roughly on axis of the solenoid and
well outside the solenoid so the magnetic field is low compared to the field
at the center of the coil. Picture the lines of magnetic field close to the
axis - at the center of the coil they are lines parallel to the axis but as
they leave the coil they slowly diverge. If the transverse energy of the
electron beam is "low" so that the cyclotron orbit diameter of an electron
about a particular line of magnetic field is small compared to the diameter
of the solenoid, the electron will spiral about that line of force and
follow it into the solenoid. Since the lines of force converge as they
enter the solenoid the electron beam is condensed, by the ratio of the
magnetic field at the electron beam source to the full field at the center
of the solenoid. The cyclotron orbit diameter is also reduced by the field
ratio. The system is symmetrical so the beam expands as it leaves the
solenoid, regaining its initial diameter as the field falls to the initial
value. This is a simple qualitative picture, of course. Because the
magnetic field lines are not exactly parallel a small retarding force is
generated. The greater the magnetic field gradient and the greater the
transverse energy of the beam the greater this force, so if you have a low
enough energy along the solenoid axis and a large enough transverse energy
and field gradient the electron will be reflected back out of the solenoid -
this is a "magnetic mirror". Conversely, a beam with high energy along the
axis, centered on the solenoid, with very low transverse energy, will
penetrate the solenoid with virtually no loss (so every magnetic mirror
leaks a little right on axis).

On one model of Nicolet (then Waters, Extrel, Finnigan) Fourier transform
mass spectrometer the filament was located outside the main field and on
axis. The filament was a strip of rhenium ribbon 0.03" wide by about 0.3"
long, in a field of about 3/7 tesla. There was a small, 2 mm orifice at the
center of the field at 3 tesla, and it was quite easy to align the filament
so the entire beam passed through this hole with no loss, with beams of 5-50
uA at 70 eV. Actually, so long as the filament was within a disc of about
0.5" diameter the beam would clear the hole. If the beam were compressed by
the field ratio it would be about 0.042" x 0.004" (about 1 mm x 0.1 mm),
half the size of the hole. In one apparatus I built the filament was moved
another two or three feet further away, and since the total range of
electron filament adjustment I had was about 1" I was actually unable to
misalign it enough to make the beam hit the edge of the hole. At 70 eV and
these currents the space charge of the electron beam is basically negligible
so each electron follows its own path with no interaction with other
electrons. At lower energies and higher currents the space charge acts to
spread the beam laterally, especially in the low magnetic field portion of
the electron trajectory, and to increase the distribution of the energy
along the axis. This smearing all acts to make the magnetic mirror more
efficient, and at low enough energy the beam doesn't penetrate at all.
Experimentally I once moved a filament from full field out to about 1/8 of
full field and measured the maximum current collected on a solid plate
behind that orifice hole, and on the orifice plate, at constant filament
power as the extraction voltage was varied. The higher the magnetic field
at the filament the higher the space charge limited current that can be
extracted from the gun, while the lower the field the more the beam will be
compressed as it traverses the solenoid so the greater the current that will
pass through the 2 mm orifice. At 70 eV it really didn't matter so far as
current goes but the alignment was much less critical at the lower field, so
the Nicolet position worked very well. Down at about 7 eV the best position
was about 10" from the orifice plate, where the field was estimated (from
memory here) at about 90% of full field. Space charge in the gun was
clearly dominating but a little magnetic compression could still be
achieved. Going all the way down to 1 or 2 eV the closer to full field the
better, in terms of current through the orifice. At this low energy space
charge between the filament and the extraction grid was all-important.
Anyway, just thought you might find some old experiments interesting :).

-----
Regards,
Carl Ijames
"Jamie M" wrote in message
Hi,

How does a solenoid act to focus a beam of electrons that are passed
axially through the coil?

cheers,
Jamie
 
M

Martin Brown

I don't think it's a very good explanation, because AFAIK if the beam
were an "ideal" infinitely narrow stream of electrons no lensing would
occur, the particles would just spiral around and around. The effect
can't be explained solely by the Lorentz force. A "simple" analysis is
supposedly offered here:
http://ajp.aapt.org/resource/1/ajpias/v77/i8/p737_s1?isAuthorized=no

...but unless you're a subscriber you'll have to pay $30 for it.

A cheaper alternative with raytraces of the paths taken is at:

http://fieldp.com/myblog/2010/designing-solenoid-lenses-for-electron-beams/

It also discusses some of the design heuristics on that site without
giving away any trade secrets.

The thing you have to remember is that no solenoidal coil of finite
length is anything like the idealised model of university physics. The
details of the fringe fields and the shapes of the exterior facing pole
pieces are important to get the things to behave exactly as required.
 
J

Jamie M

Don't know. The lenses in an electron microscope were lumps of high
purity soft iron (nickel plated to stop them rusting) that
concentrated the magnetic field generated by the solenoid inside that
- carefully shaped - lump of soft iron

http://www.microscopy.ethz.ch/lens.htm

The lens shape shown has little to do with reality. This reference
shows a schematic approximation (on page 10) which comes a little
closer to reality

http://web.utk.edu/~prack/MSE 300/SEM.pdf


Hi,

Thanks for all the replies! That is a lot of interesting information,
the only reason I can see why the solenoid coil will act asymmetrically
(different electron beam angles on the input and output of the coil)
is perhaps because of the inherent charge of the electron causing
"space charge" gradients? That picture on page10:

http://web.utk.edu/~prack/MSE 300/SEM.pdf

of the electron beam focus being proportional to solenoid current shows
the asymmetry of the input and output of the solenoid. Is that diagram
correct so that you can focus a beam to a position beyond the solenoid?

cheers,
Jamie
 
J

Jamie M

Hi Jamie,

Your question made me curious about this effect that seems pretty
non-intuitive given what we know about the magnetic field inside a
solenoid and the Lorentz force, etc. A lot of stuff seems to be behind
paywalls but I did find this reference on Google Books that seems to be
relevant:
http://books.google.com/books?id=pw...&pg=PA275#v=onepage&q=Busch’s theorem&f=false


The interaction between the magnetic field and the space charge electric
field generated by the beam is apparently pretty interesting. You'll
have to know some electromagnetic physics to follow it, but the math
doesn't look too bad.

Hi,

Also apparently if the electron is considered as an electromagnetic
wave, then using maxwell's equations gives the correct results:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electron_optics

"As electrons can exhibit non-particle (wave-like) effects such as
diffraction, a full analysis of electron paths can be obtained by
solving Maxwell's equation—however in many situations, the particle
interpretation may provide a sufficient approximation with great
reduction in complexity."

cheers,
Jamie
 
J

Jamie

Jan said:
That is the focus setup in the old vidicon system.
The electrons start spiraling in ever smaller circles, and if the field
strength is just right the focal point of the spiral is at the target.
This is because electrons like to move sideways in a magnetic field,
ever going sideways creates a spiral in your beam.

In the old vidicon deflection system the deflection coils were located
inside a bigger focus coil.
Changing the focus current (in the big coil) would also rotate the picture..

You know, it's strange how this thread comes in as I am also working on
a magnetic project that involves some research similar to what is being
discussed here.

Blowing off the dust from old notes and references that hasn't see the
light of day in years, along with new material adding to it. :)


Jamie
 
Top